Cecily Brown’s Market Is on Fire. Will This Scandal-Ridden Painting Generate Even More Heat on the Auction Block—or Get Burned?

We took to the Artnet Price Database to assess.

Cecily Brown, Faeriefeller (2019). Courtesy Sotheby's.

Those watching Sotheby’s “The Now” auction in London on Wednesday evening might do a double take when Faeriefeller (2019), an orange-hued painting by Cecily Brown, hits the block. The picture is already notorious.

It ignited the year’s biggest art industry scandal so far after Beijing’s X Museum founder Michael Xufu Huang was outed for flipping the work in violation of a resale agreement he had made with Paula Cooper Gallery. Unbeknownst to the gallery, Huang bought the $700,000 painting at Art Basel Miami Beach in 2019 on behalf of his friend, Federico Castro Debernardi, in exchange for a 10 percent commission.

Debernardi turned around and resold the work, which eventually found its way to another collector—who is now selling it at Sotheby’s. The consignor is described in the catalogue as an Important American Collection.” 

The work is estimated to fetch between £2.2 million and £2.8 million ($3 million–$3.8 million), which represents as much as a 442 percent markup from the price Huang paid just over two years ago. 

All this is to say that Cecily Brown’s market is hot as blazes right now—in fact, work by the artist appears in all three of the main houses’ London sales this week. So how did we get here? We trace the artist’s 20 years of auction history in Artnet’s Price Database below. 

The Context

Auction record: $6.8 million, achieved at Sotheby’s New York in May 2018

Cecily Brown’s Performance in 2021

Lots sold: 31
Bought in: 9
Sell-through rate: 77.5 percent
Average sale price: $1.1 million
Mean estimate: $595,700
Total sales: $35.5 million
Top painting price: $6.6 million
Lowest painting price: $400,000
Lowest overall price: $425, for a stamped fine bone china plate, part of an edition of 175 produced by Coalition for the Homeless

© 2022 Artnet Worldwide Corporation.

© 2022 Artnet Worldwide Corporation.

The Appraisal

  1. Sudden rise. While the broader art market was on fire in 2014 and 2015, particularly for young abstract painters, Cecily Brown’s secondary sales slowed down. But they returned with a vengeance in 2017, when she notched $14.9 million in total sales—nearly a third higher than her previous peak just before the financial crash in 2007. 
  2. A record year. Brown’s auction sales hit $35.5 million in 2021, a new high. Four of her ten most expensive works, including paintings in the second and third spots, sold last year. She ranked 71st in our list of top-selling artists in 2021, beating out the likes of Frida Kahlo and KAWS.
  3. Seven-figure sales. Brown’s work first crossed the $1 million threshold in 2007. Since then, her paintings have traded hands publicly for seven figures 47 times (including a splashy $5.5 million secondary market sale publicized by Gagosian in 2020). While her top ten prices at auction are all for early works, there is one outlier: There’ll Be Bluebirds (2019), which notched $4.8 million at Christie’s in October 2021. (The work was donated by the artist and her gallery Thomas Dane for charity.)
  4. Paper for paper. There is also robust demand for her prints, as she mostly makes unique monotypes. Seventeen have sold at auction for more than $10,000 each. A six-part monotype sold for a record $250,000 in 2017. 
  5. Steady interest. A total of 3,462 users searched the Artnet Price Database for the artist in 2021, down slightly from the 4,231 users who hunted for her name in 2020. Still, the number of people interested in her market exceeded those interested in that of Sigmar Polke, Ellsworth Kelly, and Robert Indiana.
  6. Great expectations. The estimate for Faeriefeller is broadly in line with the expectations for another more recent work at Phillips; there, Brown’s 2016 painting, When Time Ran Out, carries an estimate of £2 million to £3 million. Meanwhile, Christie’s is offering a more in-demand 1998 painting, The Girl Who Had Everything, for £3.5 million to £5.5 million. It last sold at Sotheby’s in 2017 for £1.9 million.

 

The Bottom Line

Despite the somewhat torrid market history, there is a good chance Faeriefeller will find a home during Sotheby’s auction tomorrow afternoon (though as of this writing, the house said the work is not guaranteed).

For one, the players involved in the embarrassment may have an interest in assuring that the work isn’t publicly burned. For another—as the saga with Huang demonstrates—Brown’s art is difficult to access on the primary market.

Collectors might be attracted to the work’s vibrant palette and pulsating brushstrokes, which demonstrate the artist’s distinct blend of abstraction and figuration. There are references both to Richard Dadd’s 19th-century masterpiece The Fairy Feller’s Master-Stroke and, as noted in the catalogue, the 1974 Queen song of the same name. Plus, as Sotheby’s Emma Baker pointed out to Artnet News, the work may be particularly desirable for collectors who prefer to own a less explicit canvas—many of Brown’s other works reference female bodies and carnal scenes.

The artist’s stellar performance at auction in 2021, paired with the market’s desire to correct its historic undervaluation of work by women, only bodes well for her trajectory. As for this particular work, it’s anyone’s guess. But those who enjoy dinner-table gossip may not consider the work’s tawdry history to be a turn off.


Follow Artnet News on Facebook:


Want to stay ahead of the art world? Subscribe to our newsletter to get the breaking news, eye-opening interviews, and incisive critical takes that drive the conversation forward.
Article topics
Subscribe or log in to read the rest of this content.

You are currently logged into this Artnet News Pro account on another device. Please log off from any other devices, and then reload this page continue. To find out if you are eligible for an Artnet News Pro group subscription, please contact [email protected]. Standard subscriptions can be purchased on the subscription page.

Log In