A Rubens Masterpiece Could Fetch $35 Million at the Auction of Divorcing Couple Mark Fisch and Rachel Davidson’s $177 Million Baroque Art Collection

A rediscovered Rubens is the star of the Fisch Davidson Collection auction at Sotheby’s.

Peter Paul Rubens, The Head of John the Baptist Presented to Salome. Courtesy Sotheby's

As a Met board member, Mark Fisch was behind some of the museum’s biggest acquisitions. As a private citizen, the retired real estate developer is now behind one of the highest-value Old Master works ever to come to auction.

When Sotheby’s opens its Masters Week on January 26, 2023, all eyes will be on Peter Paul Rubens’s Salome Presented with the Severed Head of Saint John the Baptist, a macabre early work rediscovered in 1998. Experts estimate it could sell for up to $35 million, more than five times the price paid for it at a New York Sotheby’s auction in 1998, then a record for a Rubens work at auction.

The 1609 work is one of 10 paintings from the Fisch Davidson Collection, arriving at Sotheby’s courtesy of a protracted divorce between Fisch and Rachel Davidson, a former New Jersey judge. Featuring 17th- and 18th-century masterpieces by Orazio Gentileschi, Valentin de Boulogne, and Bernardo Cavallino, the auction house is labelling the collection “one of the most important collections of Baroque art ever to appear on the market.”

Away from the auction block, the separation is notable for its potential to have a long-term impact on divorce proceedings in New York State. Lawyers of affluent clients seeking a divorce have long raced to be the first to file, often in smaller counties where they feel judges will be more conservative and partial to wealthy men, a practice known as “forum shopping.” Fisch’s attempt to file in Suffolk County, where the couple’s $4 million Southampton vacation house is located, however, was rejected by an appellate court, thereby forcing him to fight the divorce case in Manhattan.

Ahead of the January auction, paintings from the collection, which is valued between $40 million and $60 million, have been on display at Sotheby’s New York, and will later go on view in its locations in Los Angeles, Hong Kong, and London. Aside from the Rubens, highlights include Penitent Saint Mary Magdalene, a late Renaissance work by Orazio Gentileschi ($4 million to $6 million), and a recently discovered portrait by the leading artist of the French Caravaggio movement, Georges de la Tour, Saint James the Greater ($3.5 million to $5 million). Also of interest is Valentin de Boulogne’s Christ Crowned with Thorns ($4 million to $6 million), depicting a placid-faced Jesus being tormented, the early Baroque work sold for $5.2 million at Sotheby’s in 2016.

The Fisch Davidson Collection auction follows in the wake of other prominent divorce-motivated sales, such as the Macklowe Collection which netted $922 million, the most valuable collection ever sold at auction, also Sotheby’s. The January sale may lack the force of works by Warhol, Rothko, and Richter all going to market at the same time, but the circumstances surrounding the 2023 event are no less bitter.


More Trending Stories:

It Took Eight Years, an Army of Engineers, and 1,600 Pounds of Chains to Bring Artist Charles Gaines’s Profound Meditation on America to Life. Now, It’s Here

Mega-Collector Ronald Perelman Is Suing to Recover $410 Million for Art He Says Lost ‘Oomph’ After a Fire at His Hamptons Estate. His Insurance Companies Say It Looks Fine

A 28-Year-Old Who Unexpectedly Won a Dalí Etching at Auction for $4,000 Has Gone Viral With Her Rueful TikTok Video About It

Tom Hovey, the Illustrator Behind the Delectable ‘Great British Bake Off’ Drawings, on How the Show Has Catapulted His Career

The World’s Oldest Map of the Stars, Lost for Thousands of Years, Has Been Found in the Pages of a Medieval Parchment


Click Here to See Our Latest Artnet Auctions, Live Now



Follow Artnet News on Facebook:

Want to stay ahead of the art world? Subscribe to our newsletter to get the breaking news, eye-opening interviews, and incisive critical takes that drive the conversation forward.
  • Access the data behind the headlines with the artnet Price Database.
Article topics