Opinion
How Artists Reacted to the First Presidential Debate, As It Happened
Moods varied widely over an evening of political mega-theater.
Moods varied widely over an evening of political mega-theater.
Artnet News ShareShare This Article
The first presidential debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump was billed as a TV mega-event, with chatter about an estimated 100 million potential viewers. Artists, being people, tuned in and kept running commentary via Twitter.
Below, a sense of how the night unspooled on art Twitter.
As the candidates took the stage for the debate, MoMA PS1 director Klaus Biesenbach kicked off the night with the Hillary Clinton “pantsuit rainbow” meme:
tonight https://t.co/KPQlwoNAxX
— Klaus Biesenbach (@klausbiesenbach) September 27, 2016
LA-based artist Nao Bustamante was impressed by Hillary:
#Debates2016 #hillary looks flawless!
— Nao Bustamante (@NaoBustamante) September 27, 2016
Art critic Jerry Saltz (who formerly shared the airwaves with Bustamante on Work of Art) had a rather less glowing assessment of Trump:
.@realDonaldTrump neck-vagina game strong tonight. pic.twitter.com/SCmr1EbBoW
— Jerry Saltz (@jerrysaltz) September 27, 2016
Moderator Lester Holt lobbed the first question: “Are you a better choice to put money into the pockets of American workers?”
In the subsequent scrum about China and trade, painter Deborah Kass thought Clinton took the upper hand:
#debatenightwhat happens when a bully loses to a girl?
— Deborah Kass (@deborahkass) September 27, 2016
Andrew Kuo was not so sure:
Trump is winning this
— Andrew Kuo (@earlboykins) September 27, 2016
As the debate rolled on, and Trump continuously talked over Clinton, consensus crystallized that the moderator was letting things get out of hand, which is what I think Anthony Antonellis meant by this:
Kanye should be the debate moderator #debatenight pic.twitter.com/ZGT6tFUx3S
— Anthony Antonellis (@a_antonellis) September 27, 2016
NYC sculptor Adriana Farmiga was more unsparing:
Lester Holt is a spineless turd. They're letting Trump act like Godzilla on stage. Misogynistic vomit, shameful. #Debates2016
— Adriana Farmiga (@farmiga) September 27, 2016
And Sterling Crispin was already in despair:
is anyone watching the debate unsure of who they're going to vote for?
this feels like some unncessary weird schadenfreude anger-party— Sterling Crispin (@sterlingcrispin) September 27, 2016
Trump pulled out his major line of assault, blasting Clinton as a “typical politician.” Brazil-born photographer Vik Muniz thought his belligerent tone was a losing strategy:
Trump is loosing this debate by convincing everyone how unbearable it is to listen to him for thirty minutes. Can… https://t.co/iLCwDaoLpX
— Vik Muniz (@VikMuniz) September 27, 2016
Punk painter Zak Smith, on the other hand, thought Hillary was blowing it:
Like Trump is serving up such slow pitch meatballs & she's just hoping ppl will realize it's stupid but they won't without help https://t.co/wKD1ZnxWEU
— ɥʇıɯS ʞɐZ (@ZakSmithSabbath) September 27, 2016
Clinton zinged Trump for not paying taxes; Trump replied, “that makes me smart.” LA painter Lisa Adams:
"That makes me smart" you mean to cheat and lie? #aashole #Debates2016
— Lisa Adams (@lisamakesart) September 27, 2016
Hillary then pressed the line of attack that her opponent had stiffed contractors and workers in his various business endeavors. Trump: “I take advantage of the laws of the nation.” Queens museum director Laura Raicovich:
Trump: "I take advantage of the laws of the nation." Now that sounds to me like a public servant. #debate
— Laura Raicovich (@LauraRaicovich) September 27, 2016
Moderator Lester Holt weighed in: “We’re behind schedule… Let’s talk about race.”
After calling for “law and order,” Trump defended his record on race by saying he built a club in Palm Beach that allowed Jews and African Americans. Asked to defend his role in pushing the conspiracy about Barack Obama’s birth certificate, he said he didn’t need to apologize because he had performed a public service.
Painter Steve Locke:
The most honest thing Trump has said: @LesterHoltNBC asked him what he has to say for racial healing, "I say nothing." #Debates2016
— Steve Locke (@steve_locke) September 27, 2016
Then, the discussion turned to cybersecurity.
Trump: “As far as the cyber, I agree to parts of what Secretary Clinton said…” He was not finished with the statement and the mirth about “the cyber” rattled in:
Oh the cyber
— Ed (@EddFornieles) September 27, 2016
The “cyber” remark was quickly followed by Trump’s aside that cyberattacks could as easily be orchestrated by a “400-pound” homegrown hacker from his bedroom. Post-internet artist Artie Vierkant:
Willing to bet that was the first "fat hacker" haha joke ever made in a presidential debate
— Artie Vierkant (@avierkant) September 27, 2016
The debate proceeded to foreign policy. Trump’s record on the Iraq War came up for scrutiny, with the billionaire demanding that journalists “go ask Sean Hannity” to confirm that he had been against it.
Black Arts Incubator co-founder Kim Drew:
Hillary said y'all fact checkers betta turn up pic.twitter.com/KJ2rKzc8op
— kim drew (@museummammy) September 27, 2016
Trump: “I’m for NATO but they have got to get tough on terror… We have to knock the hell out of ISIS.” Against this background, Jayson Musson had an epiphany:
my mind is perpetually blown that trump is an actual presidential candidate & not a villain in an Adam Sandler movie
— Jayson Musson (@therealhennessy) September 27, 2016
The mogul then assured America of his major strength: “I have a much better temperament than she does,” a bridge too far for architecture critic Paul Goldberger:
Did Donald Trump really just say "my strongest asset is my temperament"?
— Paul Goldberger (@paulgoldberger) September 27, 2016
Clinton: “Words matter—they matter when you run for president and they really matter when you are president. We have mutual defense treaties and we will honor them.” Painter Mira Schor thought Clinton nailed it:
SHe Isn't just ready to be President, she IS President @HillaryClinton
— Mira Schor (@miraschor) September 27, 2016
NYC artist Jeanette Hayes, however, was left missing Bernie:
#debatenight pic.twitter.com/CMcFUtFzmm
— Jeanette Hayes (@jeanettehayes) September 27, 2016
Trump threw in some nasty remarks about Clinton’s stamina. Clinton clapped back: “When Donald Trump spends 11 hours testifying in front of a congressional committee, he can talk to me about stamina.”
Brooklyn museum head Anne Pasternak:
Hill has stamina! And I am so disgusted with the sexism.
— Anne Pasternak (@annepasternak) September 27, 2016
After the final, strange question about whether each candidate would support the other as president, we were through to the end.
Holt: “We covered a lot of ground, not everything, as I suspected we wouldn’t.”
Andrew Kuo, an early Clinton doubter in the debate, was relieved:
Glad Clinton did her thing. I was stressed.
— Andrew Kuo (@earlboykins) September 27, 2016
And, New York artist Joy Garnett:
Thank fucking gawd that's over.
— joy garnett (@joygarnett) September 27, 2016