Museums & Institutions
Researchers Claim Chinese Interference in French Museum Exhibitions
Respected Tibetologists have raised the alarm over the erasure of non-Han cultures in wall texts.
![a building in a cloudy city with cars zooming by in the foreground, it is at the corner of a street and there is a circular tower making the entrance, which is covered in posters a building in a cloudy city with cars zooming by in the foreground, it is at the corner of a street and there is a circular tower making the entrance, which is covered in posters](https://news.artnet.com/app/news-upload/2024/09/guimet-jiang-show-getty-1024x731.jpg)
Respected Tibetologists have raised the alarm over the erasure of non-Han cultures in wall texts.
Jo Lawson-Tancred
ShareShare This Article
A group of predominantly French researchers and scientists have published an open letter in Le Monde expressing concern that France’s cultural institutions were enabling “sinicization,” or the assimilation of non-Chinese groups into Chinese culture. They allege that Musée du quai Branly and the Musée Guimet have acquiesced to use language that “reflects Beijing’s wishes regarding the rewriting of history and the planned erasure of non-Han people.” The critique comes amid a designated year of cultural exchange between France and China.
According to the open letter’s authors, the Musée du Quai Branly, where the collection is principally made up of so-called “ethnographic objects” and indigenous art from outside Europe, has reclassified its Tibetan objects as originating from the “Xizang Autonomous Region.” This change, they say, “clearly shows the desire that Tibet, occupied and colonized since 1950, must be erased from maps and consciences, in the present as in the past.”
Meanwhile, the Guimet Museum, one of the largest collections of Asian art outside of Asia, has apparently replaced the label “Tibet” with “Himalayan world.”
The Musée du quai Branly and Musée Guimet did not respond to a request for comment by publication time.
Among the signatories on the letter are several respected Tibetologists, including Jean-Luc Achard, Stéphane Arguillère, Katia Buffetrille, and Fernand Meyer. Another of the signatories is Jacques Bacot, a dealer of furniture from the 17th, 18th, and 19th centuries. He shares a name with, and may perhaps be related to, another Jacques Bacot (1877–1965), a legendary French Tibetologist who donated his collection of paintings and bronzes to Musée Guimet in 1912.
Yannick Lintz, president of the Guimet Museum, and Palace Museum director Wang Xudong, pose after signing documents while President of Chateau de Versailles Christophe Leribault and France’s Foreign Minister Stephane Sejourne look on during the opening ceremony of “The Forbidden City and the Palace of Versailles” exhibition, which celebrates the 60th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between France and China, at the Forbidden City in Beijing on April 1, 2024. Photo: Jade Gao / Pool / AFP via Getty Images.
The letter’s authors praised the Nantes History Museum for explicitly refusing any Chinese interference in their exhibition about Genghis Khan, which opened in 2023. The museum backed out of a possible loan of objects from China after its “ran into Chinese censorship,” which apparently aimed for “the name of Genghis Khan to be erased, as well as Mongolian history and culture.”
“The People’s Republic of China’s claims to occupy these neighboring territories for the benefit of its own power alone have largely succeeded at the expense of the peoples of these territories,” the letter reads. “This is known to specialists, of course, but probably less so to those who admire the successes of contemporary China obtained at the cost of economic exploitation of these territories and merciless sinicization of these peoples, thanks to the establishment of a dictatorial regime and demographic domination by the Han.”
This year marks the 60th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between France and China, and President Emmanuel Macron designated 2024 as the official “Franco-Chinese Year of Cultural Tourism.” The Musée Guimet’s year-long “Guimet x China 2024” program concludes this November with “Chang’an: Resplendent Capital of the Tang Empire,” organized in cooperation with Art Exhibitions China.
In China, meanwhile, “The Forbidden City and the Palace of Versailles,” organized in partnership with France’s former royal residence, opened in April at the Palace Museum in Beijing. It highlights a lineage of cultural exchange between France and China during the 17th and 18th centuries. This month, the Musée Rodin will open its first international outpost in Shanghai, the same city where the ongoing Centre Pompidou x West Bund Museum Project was inaugurated in 2019.